The blogBrand and marketing

How to Check if Your Social Media Manager Is Doing Well

Likes and followers do not pay your rent. Here is a short monthly check you can run from your phone to see if your social media manager brings real customers.

7 min read

A good social media manager or agency brings you more real enquiries over time: messages, calls, WhatsApp chats, visits to your shop and orders. They can also tell you which posts or ads brought those customers. Likes and follower numbers can go up while your sales stay the same, so they are not enough to judge the work. The good news is that you can check this yourself. You need a phone, a simple notebook and about twenty minutes each month. Below is how to agree on clear goals, run a monthly check, spot warning signs, and tell the difference between a slow month and a manager who is not doing the job.

Judge by customers, not by likes

The real question is simple: are more people contacting you and buying from you because of your pages? A good manager makes that number grow over time. When you ask where a new customer came from, they can point to a post, a reel or an ad.

Most reports talk about other numbers. Likes show that someone tapped a button. Reach is the number of different people who saw a post on their screen, even for one second. Followers are people who chose to see your page in their feed. These are signals, not results. They can show that people notice you, but they do not show that anyone paid you.

Be careful when numbers rise very fast. Followers can be bought, and many of them are fake or inactive accounts. Giveaways ("like, share and tag three friends to win") also bring many new followers, but most of them want the prize, not your product. In both cases the page looks bigger while your sales stay flat.

Agree on what success means before you judge

Many owners are disappointed because the goal was never defined. One owner wants more orders. Another wants more table bookings or more clinic appointments. Another only wants a page that looks active and professional. These are different jobs. A manager cannot hit a target that nobody said out loud.

Write down one or two goals for the next three months, and decide how you will count them. For example: the number of WhatsApp orders that mention Instagram, or the number of new patients who say they found you on Facebook. The easiest method is to ask every new customer how they found you and note the answer. Ask your staff to do the same.

Also be honest about what social media cannot fix alone. If your price is too high, your product is weak, your shop is hard to find, or nobody answers messages for two days, good posts will not save the result. A good manager will tell you this. That is useful advice, not an excuse.

A monthly check you can do yourself

Once a month, pick the same day and go through these steps. Use the free statistics inside Meta Business Suite or the insights section of your Facebook and Instagram pages. A designed PDF report is nice, but the raw numbers in your own account are harder to dress up.

Keep the results in a simple notebook or spreadsheet: one line per month, a few columns. After three or four months you will see a clear trend, and conversations with your manager become much easier.

  1. 01Count the enquiries that came from social media this month: messages, comments asking for a price, calls, WhatsApp chats and walk-in customers who mentioned your page.
  2. 02Open the inbox and read some conversations. Check how fast people got a reply and whether the tone was polite and helpful. Slow or cold replies lose customers that the posts already won.
  3. 03Look at which posts got comments, shares and saves, not only likes. A save means someone wants to come back to the post later, which is a stronger sign of interest.
  4. 04Scroll through the page as a customer would. Check that it posts regularly and that colours, photos and tone match your brand.
  5. 05Compare everything with the previous months. Look at the direction over time, not one number on its own.

Green flags and red flags

Beyond the numbers, the way your manager works tells you a lot. Good managers are curious about your business. Weak ones fill a calendar and send a report.

One point matters more than all the others: your business must own the page, the ad account and the payment method. The manager should have access as a partner or employee, not as the owner. If you separate, you keep your audience, your ad history and your money.

  • Green flag: they ask questions about your customers, your best sellers and your busy and slow periods.
  • Green flag: they propose ideas tied to your season, such as Ramadan, back to school or summer, before the season starts.
  • Green flag: they tell you clearly what did not work and what they will change.
  • Green flag: they show you the ad account and how much was spent on each campaign.
  • Red flag: reports full of reach and impressions, with no mention of messages, calls or orders.
  • Red flag: generic template posts that could belong to any business.
  • Red flag: ads run from an account that belongs to them, not to you.
  • Red flag: vague answers when you ask how much was spent on ads and what it brought.
  • Red flag: you do not have admin access to your own page.

Bad month or bad manager: what to do next

Give a new manager time. In the first months they need to learn your customers, test different types of posts and find which ads work. One quiet month is not proof of bad work, especially in a slow season. Two to three months is a fair period before you judge, as long as you see effort and learning along the way.

If results stay flat after the agreed period, have a direct conversation. Bring your notebook. Show the numbers month by month, ask what they think went wrong, and agree on a clear target for the next period. If the next period also brings nothing, and the explanations stay vague, it is reasonable to change.

Finally, ask whether you need full management at all. A small shop or a single clinic may do better posting itself, using phone photos and quick replies, with help from a professional now and then for a brand look, a good video or an ad campaign. Paying less for the right help is often better than paying monthly for activity that brings no customers.

Questions people ask

How long should I wait before judging a new social media manager?
Two to three months is a fair period for most businesses. During that time, you should already see effort, testing and clear explanations, even if sales have not jumped yet. If nothing improves after that, talk with the numbers in hand.
Is a high follower count useless if it does not bring sales?
Not fully useless, because a bigger real audience can help later. But if the followers are bought or came only for a giveaway, they rarely become customers. What matters is how many of them message you, visit you or buy.
What should I always own myself when someone else manages my pages?
Your Facebook and Instagram pages, your ad account and the card or payment method used for ads should all be in your business's name. Give the manager access, not ownership. Keep your own login details and check from time to time that you are still the main admin.

Got an idea?Let’s start there.

Tell us about your project in a short intro call, and we will tell you where to start.

Or write to us at contact@benders.io